Hi all. I’m working on doing something different over the summer- I need to get involved in something that isn’t studying veterinary medicine!
Anyhow, I love to sew, quilting was my first craft art as an adult. But when I had cervical spine issues, I picked up knitting since I couldn’t bend over the machine. Then I had opposing interests when my neurosurgeon was able to return me and my neck to full duty. (I know, this is not the worst problem to have!)
Well, my knitting and the quilting can overlap in bags. I’ve yet to find the perfect knitting bag, and I’d love more than just my ideas to go on. So, here it goes. I’m going to run a raffle here and all you have to do to enter is post a list of _at least_ the top three features that every knitting bag would have.
There will be one grand prize and two runner-up prizes.
~ Grand Prize: a full-size knitting bag, designed by me taking into account ALL of the entries, in the fabrics of your choice, plus a smaller Work-in-Progress bag to match, plus a coordinated notions sac to throw into either one AND a knitting needle case of your choice- for straights, circulars, or DPN’s.
~ Runners up: a work-in-progress bag (big enough for a lace shawl project or a few pairs of socks), designed by me after taking into account ALL of the entries, in the fabrics of your choice.
When I say “fabrics of your choice,” I mean it. Anything you can find for sale in a local quilt shop, home dec store, or online, I will purchase and make the bag for you. I really need your best ideas, people, so I’m going all out on this!
You may qualify for two separate entries if you have ideas that are different for a full-size knitting bag vs a WIP bag, but not if you have 6 ideas for the full-size bag. Just make one post with all of your ideas, and I’ll keep a tally.
This raffle will be drawn on June 30th, so I will be taking suggestions and ideas for over a month, and posting prototypes for you all to see and comment on here on the blog. I hope to generate a LOT of discussion, so let's get to it!
Oh, and don't worry AT ALL about covering similar ground as other people have posted already. If it's on your top 3 list, too, that's important information for me, as well! Just post whatever matters most to you.
And, if you post anonymously, please include your ravelry ID or some other way to get in touch with you when you're the lucky winner!!!
Comments overfilled on this post. (Wowsers!!!)
Please go here to enter the contest!!!
Full size bag requirements:
ReplyDelete1) a space that will accomodate this: http://www.thermos.com/product_catalog.aspx?CatCode=HYDR&SubcategoryID=61 water bottle
2) another space that will accomodate a small tin of mints and a snack or two (I am severely hypoglycemic so these items go into any bag I carry)
3) a firm bottom so it sits and doesn't spill in the car
4) a coordinating needle pouch that will hold different types of needles such as two pair straights, one pair circs, a crochet hook AND a set of dpn's in ONE case!
a WIP/project bag should ideally have at LEAST the following:
1) eyelets to pass circular needles through so they do not interfere with the knitting inside by stabbing it or snagging it
2) a POCKET on the outside to slip said needles into so they aren't banging around and being naughty to other things in the MAIN bag... or getting damaged by sitting next to the recliner at home in full reach of a crawling infant
3) a snapped yarn guide inside to guide the strand out of the bag.
4) a drawstring that will hold a stitch counter or that *includes* a stitch/row counter of some type
5) a small inside pocket that closes to stash a few stitch markers!
How's that? I want to win!
I like a knitting bag with a big roomy main area so that I can drag my knitting in and out easliy without effort, with a little section for extras, and a closure that won't eat my yarn! A small Wip bag should have just enough room for a little project, even be able to fit easily into the larger bag or have a clip to attach it to the handles, and still have a little pocket to stash scissors, row counter, markers etc.
ReplyDeletequinn had trouble due to my comments settings, so I am posting for her. Please don't post anonymously, or I won't be able to find you!
ReplyDeleteHere's what she had to say:
1) Machine-washable. Totally.
2) Internal pockets deep enough to hold scissors, tape measure, pattern, etc. safely, but wide enough to make it easy to get your hand in the pockets to retrieve the items.
3) Lightweight enough to be able to hang the bag on a hook, doorknob, etc. with a small project inside, without damaging either bag or hanger.
Good luck in vet school, and good luck refreshing your mind when you are not in school!! :)
quinn
from abbe:
ReplyDeleteI love this!! I have yet to find the perfect knitting bag. So here goes:
1– my absolute top feature that I “would love to have but can never find” in a knitting bag is a sturdy, stiff, non-wobbly (i.e., not just a piece of fabric) divider! I’ve never come across a bag with one, but would grab it if I found it. The “dividers I have seen are all flimsy fabric and my knitting items get mixed and tangled with my “purse items.” That’s when I wind up carrying two separate bags. Again.
2– pockets, pockets, pockets. Pockets that close, not shallow pieces of fabric that don’t hold anything (you can tell I am not a fan of miscellaneous pieces of fabric in my knitting bag). Pockets of all sizes. On the outside and inside. And maybe the interior pockets could be see-through so I can find what I need on the first try. (I am really enjoying this, by the way).
3- Maybe tomorrow I will want to carry a shoulder bag. And I like my shoulder strap looooong. I don’t like to struggle to get too-short handles on my shoulders. I don’t like to struggle to get too-short handles on my shoulders..
OMG. If you made a knitting bag like this……..MWAH
from MinervaTurkey
ReplyDeleteHere are my dream bag specs:
-I need a strap drop length of at least 10 inches. Any shorter and I have to “place” the bag on my shoulder, and I like to be able to swing it up instead. Also, consider lining the straps with a non-slip fabric if possible. I have an Ameribag, and the non-slip coating on the strap keeps it in place.
-I want a fashionable bag that can be used as a purse and knitting bag in one. I like to have knitting with me at all times, but I don’t want to carry a suitcase. I need just enough room for a wallet, phone, a small pouch for odds & ends, and then 1-2 project bags.
-Pockets are a must, but I find that too many makes organization impossible. A few decent sized pockets are better than a million small ones for me.
-I LOVE external pockets for a bottle of water and maybe even a front pouch to keep my keys and phone handy.
If you make a bag with these features I am DEF buying it. :)
from lucid-sunshine:
ReplyDeleteMy ideal bag has the following features
-stands on it’s own not floppy
-zipper closure
-interior zipper and non zipper pockets in various sizes
-exterior water bottle pocket
-needs to fit over my shoulder
-a pocket I can put my wallet and phone into separate from main bag pocket
- ideally a detachable pocket/ pouch that could hold 2 small skeins of yarn for magic looping socks with out getting all tangled
- in a perfect world I’d also find a detachable needle case for my knitpicks options set.
also from lucid-sushine (my Copy-Paste error):
ReplyDeleteMy WIP bag
~2 separate pockets with grommets to feed yarn thru for the afore mentioned magic loop or 2 at a time socks
~ small pocket for notions
~ place for ID, debit card and cash or small wallet
~ place for pattern that doesn’t get all scrunched
~wrist strap
aaahhhhh to dream
from elizabethso:
ReplyDeleteOkay top qualities for a full sized bag
1- space enough for a medium sized project at least
2-I love separate pockets and lots of them. I don’t want to fish around in a big pocket for my cell or wallet, I want to know where they are
3. 3-cool shape something a little differnt from the ordinary 4. tote
4-fun fabrics- I love retro
5 I love the clips my Tom Bihn has, particularly the one for my keys, they never get lost
6. a waterproof bottom is7. nice:-)
7- easy to clean/ hard to get dirty
Project bag
1-clear bottom!
1 1/2-big enough for one(preferably two) sock projects
2-fun fabric
3-easy to wash
4-sturdy drawstring
5 signature touch(a charm or fun logo)
6-A pocket on the inside or out for a pattern would be nice
I love your q’s!!! I hope you come up with a fun prototype for us to see
My dream bag has:
ReplyDelete1) a drawstring top
2) nice and big (i have a couple of projects on the go in individual little workbags)
3) room for chocolate bar or lollies
4) room for mp3
5) i'm not one for lots of pockets i like room for a little bag with all my notions in it.
6) it has to look nice ( i really hate how some commercial bags are made with material from the 70's that even then was just shunned for it's ugliness)
8) can be spot cleaned easily ( i have 3 cats who all love my knitting)
The perfect knitting bag would have:
ReplyDeleteSome sort of clip that would keep my knitting notions kit within reach without having to dig for it.
Large enough to hold a large project but easy to carry.
Perhaps some dividers so that I could carry a small project without the yarn getting tangled in another project.
On the inside, some sort of strap of pocket to hold a pattern. I can't tell you how many times I have lost a pattern of have had one spill out of the bag or basket I am using.
Noting too deep that I get lazy and use it as a purse:0
hmmmmm... what I would like in a knitting bag. Sturdy enough to stand on its own.
ReplyDeleteShoulder straps... not too long/not too short.
A thinner section, almost file size, where patterns and a book or 2 could go... this would keep them neat.
A larger section that would hold a good size project in addition to a small project bag.
POCKETS... lots of pockets. In AND out. Velcro closures on some of the outside pockets for security. Closeable pockets inside (velcro or zipper) so things don't fall out and get lost at the bottom of the bag. Sizeable pockets so they are useful.
That would make me happy! Negal3 @ yahoo . com
1. A large section for whatever I'm working on, with a few smaller inside pockets for organizing tools and misc. items. A nice outside pocket for patterns and the like (keeping them organized and undamaged.
ReplyDelete2. A clip for keys or similar; a pocket for cell phones of various sizes and easy to retrieve from (some are a bear to get the phone out of once it's in there!).
3. A water bottle pocket, preferably large enough to hold a SIGG water bottle of .5 to .6L
4. Bag should be washable or wipeable.
5. Detachable pouches for misc. items such as measuring tape, stitch markers, needles, etc.
6. An outter pocket for a notepad and pen or pencil for those of us who are memory-challenged...
7. An outter slot for scissors, with a 'leash' to keep from losing track of said scissors, but long enough to reach the work without detaching.
8. Needle organizer, for various needles.
Okay, I am posting without reading the other suggestions, so I may be repeating things you have already received, but here goes:
ReplyDeleteFull size bag:
1. Sturdy straps that won't cut into your shoulder.
2. Magnetic snap closures - no velcro anywhere.
3. Interior pockets. It would be nice to have several interior pockets -- a couple that are tall and skinny for needles, and tall but a little wider for glasses/ reading glasses.
4. Metal ring to clip keyring or scissors on a fob.
5. Exterior pockets -- I like pockets on the front and on each end. It would be nice if the front pocket was large enough for your pattern or even large enough and sturdy enough for your pattern book.
WIP bag:
1. Pocket on the outside that a folded copy of your pattern will fit in.
2. Easy to knit from -- able to pull out project and have yarn flow without snagging. A snapped loop to guide yarn is nice.
3. Strap that can be adjusted to be used over the shoulder as a purse or carried around your waste for walking and knitting.
What a fun way to get input into your design process. Good Luck. I look forward to seeing your final products.
Lynn
lynnhaffner@kc.rr.com
My perfect bag:
ReplyDelete-has no velcro! Self-evident now, but I bought a bag with velcro when I first started knitting.
-lots and lots of pockets. Some should be easier to get to than others, and some should offer more protection that others - I need a place to keep my scissors without them poking me!
-It shouldn't be so deep that my shoulders gets eaten by the bag to get my knitting out.
-a place for pens and pencils
-a place for patterns, maybe a see through area on the outside to slip it in.
1. large enough to put a full sweater/project in it.
ReplyDelete2. lightweight, as the garment already weighs at least a lb.
3. long enough strap or handle to put on shoulder
4. a colour that won't show the dust and dirt when placed on the ground or car floor when knitting.
5. Have fun designing it.
cutlermac@yahoo.com
the perfect knitting bag -
ReplyDeleteshoulder bag, shaped like a messenger bag
interior pockets - for at least 4 cakes of yarn, plus a zip bag for all my tools
a long pocket for the pattern - full size paper sized, please
slippery fabric on the inside - smooth - on the outside, something that won't pick up lint or pet hair (so no jersey type fabrics)
a place for my cell phone, keys, wallet, personal stuff (so i don't need a purse too)
a flap with pockets for spare knitting needles, and a padded portion for sewing needles
and no velcro!! someone made me a project bag, and it had velcro all over the place - NO NO NO NO!!
and red. red would be nice :-)
A full size knit bag has to have handles or a strap that goes comfortably over the shoulder and are long enough to carry like that.
ReplyDeleteA detachable go zip up go bag to stash all of your 'bits' in (stitch markers, measuring tape etc)
An exterior pockets for keys, cell phone and wallet.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhat a fabulous idea! Here are my ideas:
ReplyDelete1. Sturdy bottom so the bag can stand up by itself!
2. Adjustable strap so it can go over my shoulder or just be carried by hand.
3. Just one strap/handle.
4. Pockets, upon pockets, upon pockets.
5. Make some of the pockets close-able (snaps?) to help contain those wiley circular needles!
For a WIP bag:
1. A ring or something to feed the yarn through as it comes out the top of the bag.
2. A divider-like see through pocket where you can put the pattern(s.
3. No zippers or anything that could snag or catch the yarn.
4. Some way to close the bag to protect what's inside (but no velcro please).
Thanks!
maddiekinsmom@yahoo.com
Your bags are beautiful! What I need most in a bag is :
ReplyDelete1. Pockects! Inside and outside.Lots of pockets. Of differing sizes, for things like extra neeles, stitch markers, other notions, and one flat one large enough to put my pattern in without it getting all messed up. Flaps and snaps are ok, just no zippers or velcro.
2. A wide, sturdy strap, that is comfortable. Preferrably one that has a grommet or hole for threading my yarn through so I don't have to remove the yarn from the bag.
3. A flat bottom. So that I can sit it down and not have everything fall out and/or get jumbled.
When you do design this ultimate bag I am sure there will be a list a mile long for one! I am going to be one of them!
Oh, I want to see the end result of all these!
ReplyDeleteMy bag wishlist:
1. Made of leather or VERY sturdy fabric. Stiff enough to not flop over.
2. Flat reinforced bottom.
3. Two WELL-DEFINED sides, not something with just a divider in the middle.
4. Corresponding pocket/bags that snap in and out so you can take out the entire thing of stitch holders or safety pins or whatever.
5. Reinforced area specifically for needles that won't let the tips poke through.
6. Top has one of those frames like a doctor's bag, so you can open it up and you can see/access the whole thing easily.
7. Wide straps long enough to carry over your shoulder comfortably.
What a great raffle... thank you!
ReplyDelete1. Flat bottom so the bag will stand up by itself.
2. Made from a fabric pleasing to my eyes rather than leather
3. Lots of pockets
4. Not so big that it gets overly heavy yet have enough room for a couple of projects.
Ok my top 3 for a knitting bag...
ReplyDelete1. Large, but with two or three different sections on the inside
2. Pockets on the inside for needles, scissors, etc--I'm thinking of something like a tool belt, but inside the bag, maybe removable.
3. Two thicker handles to make for easy parting ways to my knitting,lol.
4. A sturdy fabric that is washable--for I never know where my knitting bag is going to end up.
That is my top list for a project bag :).
Allison- alrh30@yahoo.com
Ah in search of the "Dream Knitting Bag"
ReplyDeleteMy first criteria would be size.
1. Large enough for a large project like an afghan or a sweater with plenty of extra room. Probably a minimum of 20" long X 16" tall X 8" wide.
2. I would want a zipper closure so it doesn't come undone and get dumped at the most inopportune moment.
3. I would like 1" grommets , 2 on each side to function as yarn guides. These could be placed on tabs on the inside probably at 7" from each end would be ideal. This would accomodate Fair Isle and Intarsia work.
4. I would like a large pocket on each inner side 11" X 14" to accomodate a full size pattern within a cover sleeve.
5. I would also like dividers inside the bag. I would like two segments at each end large enough to hold a full size skein of even RHSS yarn if that is what I am working with.
6. The dream bag would need a pocket inside for scissors that has a zipper so no escaped scissor mishaps.
7. The bottom needs to be firm so the bag will sit by itself and not just flop over into a heap.
8. Long handles are a requirement as I hate handbags.
9. I would love deep pockets on the outside, each side maybe with dividers for different sized items.
10. Machine washable.
11. I would absolutely adore a bag made with this fabric!
http://www.roxyyarns.com/store/shop.php/needlework-and-crafts/knitting-themed-fabric/p_335.html
or even this fabric
http://www.4my3boyz.com/product/SEWIKNITTINGYARNBALL
12. Finally a pocket for stitch markers and a row counter and other small items would be wonderful.
NOW for the perfect WIP bag:
1. Size matters. Large enough for a small to medium sized project and the yarn necessary to complete the project. I am thinking about 10" deep by about 14" long and probably 6" wide. Then it will fit nicely inside the larger knitting bag.
2. I would love a round WIP bag, perhaps a hobo style bag.
3. 1" grommets inside as yarn guides. Preferably 2.
4. Inside pocket for a pattern.9" X12" would be ideal.
5. Inside pocket for scissors, MUST have a zipper.
6. Inside pocket for stitch markers, row counters, etc. with zipper.
7. Inside pockets for knitting needles. Wide and deep enough to accomodate circular, straight and DPNS, maybe 3 of these.
8. Fabric as above, I love this fabric!
Happy adventuring into the land of the perfect knitting bag. This is an awesome idea to persue.
Hmmm....
ReplyDelete--Comfortable strap...wide enough that it does not dig into shoulder and long enough to actually fit over shoulder!
--Bag needs to close with either zipper or messenger bag-type flap...don't want all my goodies spilling out!
--Opening wide enough that I can actually "see" what is inside!!!
Those would probably be my "top 3," here are some other things I want...
--Cleanability (wipeable or washable) is a big plus!
--Fabric loops or metal rings attached where I can clip key ring, scissors, etc. also a big plus.
--Separate section where I can put items I would usually carry in a purse.
--Smaller, easily accessable pocket (on outside maybe?) where my cell phone can be...a flap or elastic to keep phone from getting lost would be good!
--If the bag is big enough, a separate, flat pocket for patterns or a book is nice
As far as the smaller project bag goes...
--again, visibility is nice...needs to open wide and be lined with lighter fabric on the inside or transparent.
--I really like to be able to hang my smaller WIP bag (for socks and similar projects) over wrist or clip to belt loop for knitting on the go
--compact and yet spacious...hmm...does that make sense?? Some bags I see seem to be bulky and take up a lot of space without actually providing much space.
--An attached row counter would be cool...or some way to hang a row counter on the bag.
Thanks for asking. I can't wait to see what you come up with!
All bags should have..
ReplyDelete1. sturdy straps that allow you to hold it without using your hands. Being able to balance it on your shoulder is essential as you need both hands to knit while you walk.
2. clean, simple lines for decoration. Yarn gets caught in buckles and oversized zippers.
A knitting bag should..
1. have at least one sturdy partition, two spaces: one for the project and one for everything else.
2. be big enough for a medium sized project (150g of yarn or less) plus the essentials of wallet, ipod, keys and cellphone.
3. be made out of firm material that it stands up on its own.
A WIP bag should..
1. be squishable without needles ever poking holes in the bag. After being thrown into backpacks and suitcases, it should still look like a nice bag.
2. have a clear pocket on its outside to slip a knitting pattern into.
3. be easily closed and opened. Snaps and zippers are better than buttons and ribbon ties.
I would like a full size knitting bag with a set of handles to go over the shoulders, and for it to cloze with a zipper.
ReplyDeleteI would like it to have 3 rather lagde rooms inside and a "slide" build in to hold pattens as not to bend them.
Then I would like the middel room to close with a zipper.
And I would love a little patcwork box in matching fabric to hold a sisor and a few others small esensial niknaks.
A smaller knitting bag for me should be simple, a round bottom and not very big. But againg a tiny matching patcwork box holding essisls would make it perfekt. And then the bag in it self shold be small enought to go inside a regula purse or a larger knitting bag.
Hope you can use some of these ideas
Great idea!
ReplyDeleteMy perfect bag would have:
1. rectangular bottom 8 X 14"
2. inner book pocket on one side and closeable pocket to fit small notions kit plus 1" to 3" pockets for crochet hooks, needle gauge and the other size needles you need for ribbing or body of a project
3. outer closeable pocket for wallet and cell phone with ring or clip for keys.
1)A strap long enough to carry over the shoulder, wide enough that it doesn't dig into the shoulder, with a no-slip backing.
ReplyDelete2) A bag that stays opened when you open it, and stays closed when you close, that stands upright.
3) Some pockets. One that will hold 8.5 x 11 pattern or magazine. Smaller pockets that close for notions, and an exterior pocket for cell phone.
From dehbiknits, who also had troubles with the comment form:
ReplyDeleteHere are my suggestions. This is pretty much reconstructed from memory. I am a bag lady (kind of) and always have bags of knitting and reading material that I drag around with me because you never know when you’ll be stranded some place and life is short!
Here are things that I find important in a project bag.
1. Able to sit up easily by itself without flopping over as I knit from it. So for that criterion to be met, it will need a bit of body.
2. A number of pockets for storage of different tools (and different types of larger tools). Maybe up to 4 pockets of a couple of different sizes. Too many pockets and it is hard to find anything!
3. Nice for the bag to be made of easy care, and durable, fabric. If it is a bag that I really like and to which I get attached, I will use it for a very long time. I have one basket type bag here that I have carried for over 20 years!
Here is a bonus! One more thing thing that I like: that when full of knitting (and maybe other stuff), it can fit under the seat in front on an airplane! I have flown with my basket for years and sometimes use it over other bags because it sits up so well!
Here are my ideas of what a perfect bag should have:
ReplyDelete1. Flat rectangular bottom so it can sit flat without toppling over
2. machine washable & dryable
3. no zippers and such on the inside to snag my yarn
4. zippered pockets on the outside to hold wallet, cell phone, etc
5. must be able to close fully, so items cannot fall out. And it stays open when it is open & stays closed when closed
6. 2 straps long enough that I can throw it over my shoulder and the separate when I open the bag & remain out of the way
7. very roomy on the inside with one divider so that project can go in one section & everything else can go in the other. And a large flat pocket on the inside, large enough to slip patterns into
1. machine washable and dryable.
ReplyDelete2. waterproof would be a really nice bonus
3. pockets- mostly on the inside for holding stuff
4. appealing color, and I like quilted too.
5. matching little bag is a neat bonus...
Nurselisa13 on Ravelry-can't figure out how to post my name...
Ooooh, I love knitting/WIP bags. I have a ton and not one of them has everything I need in a bag.
ReplyDeleteLet's see, my perfect knitting bag would have the following options:
1. A stiff bottom and sides that sit more or less upright.
2. A small zippered pouch, or three, on the inside for yarn needles, stitch markers, counters, etc. Notions bags are great, but I find they're more annoying than not (even though I still carry one)
3. Lots of pockets/dividers. A place to put my needle set, my crochet hooks (both sets are in a zippered pouch already, but it'd be great to have a place to put them so they don't end up in the very bottom of the bag).
4. A large pocket on the outside (one on each side would be good too) for magazines/books/patterns so they don't get crushed and bent inside the bag.
5. A small area to put keys and a wallet, when I'm heading out to a knitting group gathering I don't need to bring a purse AND a knitting bag, but more often than not I find myself doing it because otherwise the wallet/keys work their way to the bottom of the bag and I have to dig through a pile of stuff to find them. Ok, so really this falls under more dividers.
6. For a WIP bag I'd like some of the same features actually. A small zippered pocket inside for notions, a place for wallet and keys, maybe a small pocket to fold up a copy of the pattern too.
Hmm, I could actually go on and on, but I won't!
This is so exciting! Lets see...
ReplyDeleteBig enough main compartment for a largish project.
NO zippers or velcro to snag my yarn.
Light colored, slippery inside lining, so yarn balls unwind smoothly as I knit.
Bonus: Machine washable would be awesome, but not required.
PS - after looking at your AskAVetStudent site - I'd like to recommend that you learn a bit about rabbits (which are not rodents, btw). They are the best kept secret of the pet world. Very smart, outrageously funny, and capable of using a litterbox. Our 3.5lb houserabbit loved playing with, and bossing around, our three huge cats until her passing last summer at the age of 9. Their body language and digestive systems are very different from more common pets, but they are well worth taking the time to learn. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteHere's a great site: http://language.rabbitspeak.com/rabbittalk.html
From Lisa knits and sews and knits (via email):
ReplyDeleteAh the quest for the perfect bag. Yes I have looked long and hard, and also have muddled with the idea of making my own.
Was thinking of modifying a pattern to suit my needs. This is in my sewing stash. simplicity 4746.
Got it cuz I also liked the jacket. But as yet the yarn stash has been calling my attention... although when I went surfing for this pattern, saw no shortage of patterns that might be modifiable into the ‘ultimate bag’
I would make this bag wider and taller. I love the outside pockets shown in the pic.
Not sure if there are inside pockets.
Other requirements:
The idea of a grommet for keeping WIP yarn under control is nice, but then the yarn/wip is married to the bag. Nogood.
So how about an instead-of-grommet idea that allows for removable if desired. Snap?
Perhaps my ultimate bag? Buy pattern from you that includes details from the best of the excellent suggestions offered so far.
Apparently I posted this under the wrong blog entry; let me try again:
ReplyDeleteWhat beautiful bags you've made! I don't currently have a real knitting bag and have been looking for the "perfect" bag for a while now, but have yet to find it. Here are some of the features I am looking for in a knitting bag:
1) Roomy without being overly big. I'd prefer it to be deeper rather than tall and wide (if that makes sense).
2) Lots and lots of pockets, both inside and out of various sizes.
3) It MUST close at the top so that the contents don't spill out and so that cats (and kids) can't get in easily. Velcro is obviously a no-no and I'm not a fan of zippers either. I think a drawstring top would be best.
4) Ideally, the fabric should be cotton and/or silk (I'm a fiber snob, can you tell?) but also needs to be washable in a pinch.
My requirements for the WIP bag are essentially the same:
1) It should have a carabiner so that it can easily attach to various things such as purse handles, belt loops, etc.
2) Again, lots of pockets
3) Again, a drawstring top
4) Again, made of washable cotton/silk
What a great idea! Thanks for letting us give you input!
I didn't read anyone else's post - so I don't know if these are repeats:
ReplyDelete1. An over the shoulder bag that doesn't hang down too low and actually stays on the shoulder and can be worn at the side or pushed behind your elbow to rest more on your back.
2. Pockets - at least 3 or 4, not too many more, or you have to dig through all of them to fine the one thing you are looking for. I would like two inside, one zipped one not, but that is deep enough that things don't fall out, and two outside one zip one not.
3. Waterproof or at least resistant. And lined - so there are no corners for stitch markers and other little stuff to get lost in.
WIP
1. Something that works so that you can knit while you are walking
2. A drawstring is nice
3. Two compartments - so the wip is in one side and the pattern is on the other, it would be super cool if the part for the pattern had a plastic window so you didn't have to take it out to look at it. bonus if you can write on the plastic window with dry erase! And a pocket for the scissors, measuring tape etc.
A zipper at the top.
ReplyDeleteAt least one pocket for notions
Strong enough lining not to be torn by needles and scissors floating within.
Big enough to actually hold my whole sweater projects.
1. The bag should be large enough to be able to put the knitting needles in it without them sticking out! I have a bag that is roughly 1/2" too short to accomodate the needles!?!?!
ReplyDelete2. Pockets that actually hold things. Various sizes, some that are open top but deep enough to hold items without them falling out and some having flaps to close. And a pocket large enough to hold the pattern.
3. Would like a bag that has a closure, but not velcro as this is easy but always seems to snag the yarn.
4. A sturdy divider so you can keep the WIP and the working yarn/extra yarn apart.
5. A bag that doesn't collapse down upon itself when you have things in the pockets.
I would love a bag that :opens wide enough that I can see everything in it.
ReplyDelete:has pockets on the insides sides so I can stash misc. items, cellphone, mp3player
:has at least one big secure pocket with a zipper so I can put keys and a small wallet in it and not worry about them falling out.
For a full size bag I like a bag that will stand on it's own, ideally with a non-cloth bottom (where it always get dirty). Inside pockets that zip closed with non-nylon zippers. An outside pocket for a cell phone is required!
ReplyDeleteFor a small project bag, no drawstrings, handles only (short) plenty of zippered pockets, fabric that can be cleaned easily and a detachable long handle in case you want to carry it like a shoulder bag.
1. Opening that does not catch yarn and allows me to work with my ball still in the bag.
ReplyDelete2. Either compartment or clip-in coordinating pouch for my accessories.
3. Made from tough enough material to keep the needles from poking through.
My top requirements for a full-size knitting bag:
ReplyDelete1. Sturdy-ish sides. Not rigid or anything, but not floppy when it's sitting on the ground. It should stand up on its own.
2. Inside organization. A divider would be good to keep projects separate. Inside pockets (on each side) to hold needles & accessories (scissors, tape measure, etc.) And a flat side pocket to keep patterns or books.
3. The straps have to be good. Long enough to put on one's shoulder comfortably, not slippery so it slides off your shoulder, attached really securely. And, I'm not sure if this would be workable, but if the straps could be adjusted so you could also wear the bag messenger style that would be great.
Requirements for a WIP bag:
1. Nothing anywhere that could possibly snag any type of yarn. NO VELCRO! or zippers. Magnetic closures would be good I think. This would also serve as a yarn guide.
2. Smaller inside pockets for needles/accessories... when I drop a stitch and need a crochet hook stat, I don't want to have to dig for it.
3. Should also be wearable as a purse... not a clutch sort of thing.
For both:
1. washable
2. must not look lame! :)
ps contact info. elaine.christian at gmail.com
From WireWoman:
ReplyDeleteI want a bag to be very well made with a lot of inner compartments and zippered flaps on outside. I don’t own a car and have to haul everything around on foot or ride buses for transportation, so I prefer squishy to shaped. Because I KIP a lot (even standing in line - especially standing in line!) I need instant access - and so on…
Another idea that might be useful - before designing, why not take some time to determine your style:
- how do you transport your ‘stuff’ in general? Do you own a car? Do you use a backpack most of the time?
- do you like to carry one or more projects? At what stage do you leave a project at home? Do you carry projects that are worked on ONLY in public or away from home?
- what size and type of knitting tools do you need to have with you?
- how much weight can you safely haul around (some of the really nifty bags I’ve seen at LYS weighed more than what I would have put in them!)
1. At least one large space for a sweater-sized WIP.
ReplyDelete2. A separate compartment large enough for patterns.
3. Many smaller pockets for various knitting accessories (stitch markers, needles, hooks, scissors, etc), possibly a few of these large enough for smaller projects--say, sock-sized.
4. A real closure such as a zipper.
5. Waterproof would be nice...but isn't absolutely necessary
1. pockets, pockets, pockets
ReplyDelete2. a zipper to keep my 1-year-old out of the yarn
3. a separate section to keep the yarn ball with a grommet to feed the 'active' yarn to my project
4. did I mention pockets?
I haven't had a chance to read thru everyone's ideas, but plan to return - I'm sure there are some wonderful suggestions. I imagine these have been suggested, but I want to enter so:
ReplyDelete1. sturdy material, w/ a good secure closure that's also easy to open & keep open. I think in my experience a square or rectangle shaped bag can hold things better than a round one.
2. lots of pockets, which I'm sure isn't a novel idea, but I think I'd like clear pockets in order to be able to see what's inside them. I know it wouldn't be as attractive but I always dig thru pockets trying to find what I'm looking for. Or if not clear, then maybe design some sort of little pocket on the outside of each pocket to slip in a label to help identify/organize what goes into each pocket. Again, w/ experience, outside pockets seem to help me organize myself better than inside dividers or pockets. Various shapes to hold small objects or long needles...
3. The inside of the bag should be light colored to help see inside.
Okay, important things for bags are:
ReplyDelete1) Supportive handles. They need to be long enough so you can have it on your shoulder, and you don't have to be careful about putting a lot of stuff in them.
2) A little pocket on the inside for scissors and stitch markers, etc. It's also cool if it has a little, like, elastic loop to put a darning needle through. I have trouble with that and tend to lose mine.
3) Washable. My bags go with me to a lot of places, and being able to wash them without worrying about anything happening to the bag ios good.
For the WIP bag specifically, it needs:
1) Lining. too many of my fabric bags have gotten poked with needles.
2) Also needs a small inside pocket for little notions and such. Having a flap or a button to close the top of the bag is also nice.
3) Big enough to fit a pattern in. I have my patterns in my folder (which has an awesome picture of a giraffe on the front), and its nice to be able to fit that in so the patterns doesn't get messed up.
My perfect Knitting Bag would come with a knitting guru. Lots of pockets, lined with a thicker tougher lining then that silky easy for needles to poke through stuff you see in most bags, and would be in a variety of colors from solids to stipes or you "fabric paint" design it etc.
ReplyDeletefull sized bag top 3:
ReplyDelete* pockets! (including some on the outside for keys & cell phone) but not too many loops/buttons/other things sticking out on the inside
* a detachable pouch or two with zippers to hold stitch markers and notions
* 9x12" slot for pattern pages; plastic lined would be nice
WIP bag top 3:
* waterproofing (or at least resistance) and poke-through-proofing (losing needles through one's bag stinks)
* adjustable strap long enough to sling across the body for knitting-while-walking
* secure closure with an opening for yarn to feed through and not snag (draw strings seem ok for this; zippers are less good)
more thoughts for both:
machine-washable is definitely a plus
handles long enough to comfortably wear over the shoulder; thick fabric is nicest IMO
no velcro
not too heavy on its own
My dream knitting bag would have no zipper or velcro to snag knitting.
ReplyDeleteover the shoulder handle/strap
long skinny pocket for extra needles/crochet hook
pockets for scissors, gauge ruler, etc. on the outside
easy care - machine wash fabric
large but not heavy
strong fabric with good body so it doesn't flop over
flat bottom that will stand easily
large pocket to hold patterns on outside of bag
beautiful fabrics like drapery/upholstery weight.
samm @ ravelry
This is an awesome thing to think about and I hope that you get some great ideas from this!
ReplyDeleteMy ideal knitting bag would include:
1) I love compartments, that would perhaps be set up for...
- needles/needle rolls
- stitch markers, row counters, etc.
- books or patterns
2) A dividers on the inside so I can maybe keep projects on one side and extra yarn on the other without getting things tangled, or one project on each side.
3) Something relatively lightweight but sturdy. I know my knitting can get heavy so don't want the bag to add too much to that!
As for the WIP bag:
1) Also should have a compartment on the inside to hold notions
2) I tend to use this type of smaller bag for smaller projects, such as socks. It would be great to have a place to tuck DPNs that aren't being used so they don't get lost.
3) Again, a small flat pocket in which to put a copy of a pattern.
I can't wait to see what the end result is!
~Natalie~
My idea of a perfect knitting bag would have the following features:
ReplyDelete1. Light colored lining, making it easier to see what's in the bag.
2. Most outside pockets/compartments would have some sort of a closure.
3. Not so big that it becomes a dumping ground for ufo's. But big enough that the bag would hold a small purse.
4. The top of the bag would open wide so that items inside are easy to see and locate.
5. Light weight bag.
6. Shoulder strap.
Good luck on finding your perfect bag
dogwalker
Hmmm my bag,
ReplyDelete1. Sectioned so yarn does not become tangled and easy to get to.
2.cell phone and water pockets
3. Washable
4.Straps to come about to the waist and able to hang
5.A section for magazine or pattern
6.Snaps no zipper
This is so exciting! Here is what I absolutely LOVE in a knitting bag
ReplyDelete1. Outer pockets to hold a ball of wool. The pocket would have an opening where you could thread the wool through so you can do intarsia knitting and not get your skeins in a jumble!
2. Elastic loops of the inside that would hold on to various lengths and width of knitting needles.
3. Pockets Pockets Pockets! Pockets of all shapes and sizes to hold all of your smaller knitting necessaries-i.e. stitch markers, needle tips, etc.
4. Closures that are snaps or buttons. It sucks getting a lovely alpaca yarn caught in velcro or a zipper!
5. An adjustable strap with some extra padding. I need this because I often take my knitting bag to the air port with me and having an adjustable strap means that the knitting bag doesn't have to fight for space with my purse and lap top bag. The extra padding is nice because I typically have a HEAVY old school knitting manual-just in case I make a mistake.
6. Some kind of bag protector on the bottom that would keep the bag off of the floor-maybe little plastic rests or a waterproof fabric on the bottom. Aside from not liking my bag to touch the dirty floor (I knit in cafes a lot) having the bottom protected is a good idea in case something wet is on the floor. Wet wool inside a knitting bag is no good-a wet pattern is not good either.
Thanks for having this contest! I am sure you will create an AWESOME knitting bag! I've been knitting for 7 years and I am just now picking up quilting. I'm working on my first project and I think I am addicted to quilting!
1. It needs to close so that when you hit the brakes and the bag tumbles onto the floor, the white linen yarn doesn't fall on the dirty minivan floor.
ReplyDelete2. It should sit solidly on the floor and not tip over.
3. It should have a good place to store a pattern.
I'd also go for machne washable and a place to hold my water bottle!
1. I would like it to have a zipper top so everything doesn't fall out if it falls off the seat of the car or couch.
ReplyDelete2. I also would like an outside pocket for keys, cellphone, and etc.
3. I would like it to sit on the floor without turning over.
4. Machine washable if possible.
Knittingdancer on Ravelry
Ideas for wips: 1)about a foot tall, round with drawstring closure 2)also has comfortable straps so it can ride well on shoulder 3)again, pockets all around the inside 4) I think some kool, funky fabric with ric-rac or beaded fringe if it looks good with the fabric 5)pocket on the outside as well.
ReplyDeleteok, my ideal knitting bag... well, first, my favorite bag right now is a knitting stand from Joann's. The wooden frame allows it to stand on it's own, but the fabric allows me to stuff it full, and it will stretch a bit. It has one section, with a small pocket in the inside, and a larger pocket on the outside. My only real complaint is the handles are too close to the frame, so there is barely enough room for my to fit my fingers in between. That and the frame keeps coming apart, so I keep having to glue it and tie it with yarn. This is not my "ideal" bag, just the best I've found so far.
ReplyDeleteMy ideal knitting bag would have:
-a water bottle pocket, large enough for a decent sized water bottle
-a pocket on the inside, large enough for a cell phone, maybe a wallet, or some cash and ID, and an ipod. Big enough to hold all these things and be able to get them out easily, but not so big they are falling all over the place
-over 11 inches long (so you can put in a pattern without folding), with a slim pocket on the inside for patterns
-pockets that can hold notions needles, etc, or hold other small bags with these items (instead of just tossing them into the main compartment and having them get mixed up with the yarn, and an extra pocket for a snack (like a chocolate bar), tylenol, etc
-a pocket on the outside, not for anything in particular, but just to have as another place to put things
-an adjustable strap so I can put it over my shoulder or carry it with my hand. if you can come up with a strap that adjusts easily (something other than the typical adjuster on purses... maybe a way to snap the middle of the strap to one end? does that make sense?)
-a strap that is wide enough to be comfortable, but not so wide it will dig into my neck when I put it on my shoulder
-something that is stiff enough to sit on it's own (and waterproof bottom is nice), without collapsing, but not so stiff it's hard (I want to be able to shove it under my legs in the car, or in another smaller space) I like softer bags, but not limp
-washable would be great, but I would settle for easy to clean
-a way to close the top (like a zipper or something) so that if it gets tipped over, everything doesn't fall all over the place
-this is where the magic really comes in, I want it to be roomy enough so that even with the pockets full, there is still room for my yarn and project. Most bags I've seen that have pockets on the inside, by the time the pockets are filled, they fill the inside of the bag!
-one of my biggest pet peeves on interior pockets is when they are flimsy and gape open at the top. especially on larger pockets (like one that runs the length of the bag to put patterns in).
I'm rolyknitter on Ravelry, feel free to get in touch if anything I said doesn't make sense!
1. Deep enough for a whole project- at least 6-10 balls worth, plus book/pattern and hooks. But not terribly wide. I like the idea of a sturdy flat bottom too.
ReplyDelete2. A pocket for small goodies-scissors, stitch markers, etc. with a zipper to keep it all from running away.
3. Slightly long handles, because when the bag is stuffed full you need a little extra length to reach across.
1. Sturdy fabric.. I knit mostly socks and find my needles poke through most bags.
ReplyDelete2. Outside zipper pockets.. those inside pockets are great, and necessary. But it would be great to be able to dig out your tape measure without having to take out 16 balls of yarn first.
3. Roomy.. expanding gussets, wide, sturdy, flat bottom. And please, no more top heavy bags. I hate using my bags that are tall and skinny because they fall over if you put much in them. (And who wants to use a huge bag that will only comfortably hold enough yarn for a scarf or sock?)
4. Options in closures.. some people want a zipper. Some people want a drawstring. Some people want a snap. It would be nice to be able to choose how the bag closes when you order it.
5. Affordable... I know how much handmade is worth, but realistically I don't have $75 laying around to spend on a bag. :(
From knittergma:
ReplyDelete1. Light weight but has body so it doesn’t flop when it sits down
2. Snap top
3. Shoulder straps, but not too long so you could hand carry it also.
4. Lots of pockets inside for all the things knitters are known to carry.
5. A flat bottom
6. And ECO, “Think Green”
7. A pocket for a water bottle so it doesn’t tip over.
1) A sturdy bottom so it will stand up when placed on the floor or in the car.
ReplyDelete2) Large enough pocket inside to stuff the actual sock in progress, the thought is to keep the work on the needles, if I just toss it in, usually I loose one needle.
3) As many pockets as you can possibly stand to sew. I love many many pockets, I feel like I can get very organized if I have a place for everything.
I'd like to see:
ReplyDelete1. A separate pocket/sleeve for pattern. Now I just throw my pattern in the bag and everything goes on top of it and it tends to get wrinkled/mangled.
2. If possible, a separate compartment for wallet/keys/phone so I don't have to carry a purse, too.
3. Sturdy fabric with handles that are attached well/reinforced so they don't pull off.
Knitastic said...
ReplyDeleteHi Jenn,
Great idea... I love the bags you have displayed. My top 3 choices would be:
1. Secured Top (zipper, closeur of some sort that does not snag the yarn) to keep the knitting inside and unwanted items outside.
2. Plenty of pockets for all the notions.
3. Inside lining that makes it easy to see into the bag. Nothing too dark.
For a project bag:
1. grommet (spelling) to be able to pull yarn through.
2. Snag free zipper
3. Small pocket inside for notions.
Thanks,
Robbin
moosmutzel said...
ReplyDeleteFor a knitting bag
1) at least two seperate big parts on the inside - one for projects one for personal things, like wallet etc.
2) Adjustable handle (long to short)
3) Needle holders in different sizes or made of elastic (the one knitting bag I have has fabric needle holder loops that are all to big for my needles)
WIP bag
1) drawstring
2) hook to attach it to bigger (knitting bag)
3) very flexible material that the bag itself is not to bulky
Valerie J said...
ReplyDeleteI love the drawstring bag at the bottom of your samples.
My wishes would be for hook or loop to be able to attach it to another bag or belt....waterproof like nylon which would also make it lightweight...a adjustable big opening so you can open it all the way to see inside & to fit a larger skein without squishing it.
Anonymous said...
ReplyDeleteHMMMM Lets think, Well,
1. Large opening to pull things out,
2.Inside pockets for needles
3. Large outer pocket for magazine or patterns.
WIP:
Drawstring
easily washable fabric
Inner pocket for small items
(if this is your comment from the "some of my bags" post, please send me an email and let me know your name and contact info.)
operaknitter said...
ReplyDeleteI like the second bag with the wider shoulder.
My ideal bag would have:
1) a large bucket-styled mouth with draw-sting closure. (Some cute beads or buttons on the ends.)
2) An equally large base so that the bag can "sit" by itself on the floor, or wherever you´re knitting. Something like a knitting basket.
3)) Should still be collapsable to store and soft sided for traveling.
4) Water proof on the outside? I´m usually on foot, wouldn´t want my knitting to get wet, heaven forbid! Also in case I spill coffee or anything on it (horror!)and this way it´s easy to clean.
5) Inside should have tons of pockets along the side of the "bucket". Long enough for straight needles, some shorter ones for dpns, and other things like stitch markers, pins.
6) How about attaching a tape measure somehow? A knitter can always use one. And a little "key chain" holder for keys as well as sissors maybe?
Outside pocket for purse and cell phone.
7) Fabric should be bright and modern-looking. No Granny bags please.
8) handles could either be cloth or how about a "Gucci"-stlye bamboo type of round handles?
9) Inside soft, non-scratchy for yarn. Reversable, maybe?
10) Has to be inexpensive enough to want to "collect". Different ones for different projects? Fabric could be themed by colors or something?
11) Sometimes I like to pin buttons on the outside of my favorite quilted one like from Ravelry, or wherever. Has to be forgiving enough fabric for that.
12) What also could be cute is personalize the bag with monograms on the outside? a la LLBean?
13) Lastly, pockets, pockets and more pockets. For everything!!!
Kate said...
ReplyDeleteWhat beautiful bags you've made! I don't currently have a real knitting bag and have been looking for the "perfect" bag for a while now, but have yet to find it. Here are some of the features I am looking for in a knitting bag:
1) Roomy without being overly big. I'd prefer it to be deeper rather than tall and wide (if that makes sense).
2) Lots and lots of pockets, both inside and out of various sizes.
3) It MUST close at the top so that the contents don't spill out and so that cats (and kids) can't get in easily. Velcro is obviously a no-no and I'm not a fan of zippers either. I think a drawstring top would be best.
4) Ideally, the fabric should be cotton and/or silk (I'm a fiber snob, can you tell?) but also needs to be washable in a pinch.
My requirements for the WIP bag are essentially the same:
1) It should have a carabiner so that it can easily attach to various things such as purse handles, belt loops, etc.
2) Again, lots of pockets
3) Again, a drawstring top
4) Again, made of washable cotton/silk
What a great idea! Thanks for letting us give you input!
Gaela said...
ReplyDeleteYour sewing skills are very apparrent, these are just lovely bags and wips and needle holders. Funny, I've been trying to come up with the perfect bag myself for a while, so this will be great in many ways. 1) large, round, bucket style, and deep 2)pockets all the way around the bottom of the bag, and the pockets can be different heights with the lowest being just a bit lower than halfway up. 3)straps that are wide enough and long enough to carry as a shoulder bag. 4)could also be carried as a backpack.
What a great idea for a contests! Here are my requirements:
ReplyDeleteFull size bag requirements:
1)POCKETS, and lots of them. They need to be deep enough that notions do not fall out. I also want a pocket at least big enough to hold a folded in half 8 x 11 sheet of paper with a pattern on it- even better if the pocket does not require the pattern to be folded.
2) I'm not even sure if this is possible, but I would love a removable interior divider. Sometimes, I take my knitting somewhere, and I want to put two projects in the bag, or put my project and a book in the bag, or something, and it's easier if there's a divider. Other times, I need the full-size main compartment.
3) A nice, firm, flat bottom so that I can set it down and it won't fall over.
4) No zipper or velcro, as these can both get yarn stuck in them.
WIP Bag requirements:
1)A carabiner. I love being able to clip a smaller WIP bag onto something, so that I don't have to carry it. Sometimes, I'll even clip it onto my belt loop.
2) REALLY sturdy fabric. I'm tired of my needles poking through!
3) A drawstring closure.
My perfect yarn/knit/crochet bag would have the following attributes:
ReplyDelete1) Machine washable with removable stiff inserts that add structure, mostly to the bottom of the bag...but also some dividers.
2) Have grommet holes already (meaning I don't have to hammer them in), so I can pass the yarn through without opening the bag up all the time.
3) Have a seperate needle/hook/tool bag that attatches securely to the main bag.
4) Would have to be made with some of the cool retro fabrics out today with my favorite colors of brown, teal, green, orange and burgandy ~ish.
5) Would also accomidate my other needs without getting in the way of my project....a place for the keys (like a hook on the outside of the bag so I don't have to dig around), a place for the ipod, snacks and so on.
Your bags are very pretty...and I'm not saying that to get any brownie points either, lol.
full size bag:
ReplyDeletesturdy fabric. lined so it'll wear better.
enough room for needles and notions as well as a large project.
a structured design so that the bottom will stand up.
WIP bag:
sturdy/lined
structured design (i love box bags with the handle they have) most drawstring bags i've seen don't look sturdy enough (and most aren't structured)
well-placed handle(s). i love the box bag design with the handle on the side.
I love this raffle! So here are some desires on my part:
ReplyDeleteFor the large bag:
1. A stiffened flat bottom. It sits more easily on the floor, and it makes it much easier to find (heck even organize) different projects or materials. If you can get little feet on there to slow wear and tear, even better!
2. I sing the love of interior pockets! I'm with all the folks who are asking for some kind of interior dividers -- perhaps one flat pocket along one side for patterns or mags, and smaller ones along the other for scissors, other notions. If you can sort out interior dividers in the bottom for the notions sack, etc, so much the better!
3. Handles that will sit over my shoulder without sliding off. Please, pretty please.
4. Tough and well-sewn enough to withstand actual use!
Full size knitting bag:
ReplyDelete1) 2 straps (2" wide, 30" long)
2) One outside pocket big enough for a water bottle.
3) One inside pocket for a notions bag - at least 8" wide and 6" deep.
Thanks for asking - good luck with this project.
Full-sized Bag -
ReplyDelete1. A divider in the bag so it can double as my purse. Also, pockets that line the inside walls for cell phones and such.
2. Large but not HUGE (6" X 8"-ish and it can't look like a tote bag). Comfortable straps.
3. Feet. I need to be able to put it down without worrying about getting it (or anything inside it) dirty.
WIP Bag -
1. Attachable/removable matching notions bag
2. Soft and collapsible to stuff into my "real" purse .
3. No crazy about drawstrings - they never close all the way and little markers/such can escape!
1. Water resistant! I am, for some reason, always caught in the rain with my knitting. It doesn't have to be waterproof, just able to handle a brief run by a sprinkler.
ReplyDelete2. The opposite of a tote bag. Tote bags have everything I would want, size-wise, in a knitting bag, but lack pockets, secure closures, handles of a decent length, and style.
3. Flat, solid, bottom with feet. I bring my knitting into some "interesting" places and I like to keep the bag from picking up what's on the ground, you know?
4. Pockets everywhere, inside and out. Deep pockets. Small pockets. Gusseted pockets. Pockets for a water bottle/umbrella. Pockets with snaps, pockets with clasps. Pockets everywhere of every size and of closure method, but at least two outside ones for keys/phone and a bottle of water.
5. This sort of goes with #4, but a designated place for purse-like objects. Either a way to clip the knitting bag to the purse, or a way to keep purse objects completely separate. Perhaps a completely-closed off compartment?
6. Collapsible. I am a tiny person, and when the bag takes up more space than I do it is comical. Gussets for the win.
7. Does not fall over when placed on the ground (see #3). Make this sucker bottom-heavy, because a top-heavy bag is not fun to find things in.
Full Sized bag:
ReplyDelete1) Quite professional looking so not just used for knitting because usually I have a bit of everything in my life in my bags.
2) good straps, especially with a heavy load
3) will sit on surfaces without damage - my bags, if it's the chosen one, it's used constantly and must withstand it all
WIP bag
1) more creating fabric - probably matching the lining of the full sized bag
2) mini zippered pocket for notions
3)squishable bag - for being placed anywhere =)
I told you I would post this!
ReplyDeleteTo me the things most important on my knitting bag are:
1.) Has a strap long enough to be slung over my shoulder.
2.) Has lots of pockets, which are on the inside so that things do not fall out as I galavant around town
3.) Is made of a tough material with a cute/fun material inside that is a bright color so I can find things.
Good luck with the contest!
-Kim
I'd love to share my ideas for a knitting bag:
ReplyDelete1: has to sit on the floor and stand up when open. No slouching over.
2: It has to zip fully closed. I'd prefer to also be water resistant. I live in Florida and do not want my stuff to get wet.
3: It has to be able to carry several project.
For a WIP Bag - I like to keep my projects seperate within my knitting bag.
1: It needs to be big enough that I can put my DPS inside the bag too.
2: Bright colors - easy to find in my knitting bag.
3: Complete closure - whether by zipper or pull string with a stopper.
I haven't read through all of the posts. This is a topic that I have spent a lot of time on. Here goes:
ReplyDelete1-Must have and inside pocket that DPN needles can be slid into. Must be stiff enough so that any bending or pushing to the bad will not break any wooden needles. Maybe some kind of pocket protector thingy inside of it.
2-grommets in the sides of the bag so that yarn can be threaded from the inside to be knitting from the outside of bag. I haven't gotten the logistics of that one yet.
3-pockets on the inside of various sizes. Need one to hold books. some smaller ones to hold stitch markers. Need loops to hold circular needles. Pocket on outside end of each side of bag to hold longer needles/with a flap to close over them. smaller pocket to hold tape measure, pens, notepads, etc.
Sholder straps that can be adjusted to hang from shoulder.
I could go on and on.
This question gave me the opportunity to vent. LOL I will be dreaming about the perfect bag. -Kat
My ideal knitting bag would be showerproof so I could take my WIP in it to my Stitch'n'Bitch club in damp weather without everything geting wet and the pattern becoming papier mache, and so the outside could be sponged clean on a regular basis. PVC coated cotton would be perfect.
ReplyDeleteA large main section to hold my knitting and at least one spare ball of yarn. Lots of pockets - inside and some zipped ones outside so I don't lose tape measure, notebook, pen, stitch markers and all the other bits we find so essential in a jumble at the bottom of the bag. I keep my markers and things in their own little tins but it would be nice to have lots of pockets to keep them in.
A solid bottom to the bag and a lining that needles won't poke through if I forget to put stops on the points.
A strong and adjustable shoulder strap that stays adjusted to the length I want it.
My top 3 would have to be:
ReplyDelete1) Many, many pockets of different sizes. If I'm going to take it to my knitting group, I'd love pockets large enough for my cell phone and wallet, as well as smaller pockets for needles, hooks, etc. At least one zippered pocket, so I can keep keys in there and they won't snag my yarn.
2) Very sturdy fabric. I take my bag everywhere. It has to survive classrooms, coffee shops, the floor of my car, etc. Even better would be stain-resistant or slightly waterproof.
3) I'd love a matching notions case or needle case, especially with lots of little organizational sections. My main need is for better organization so I'm not always digging around for what I need.
Oh I'm so sorry! My post is from Lesleyluu at Ravelry.
ReplyDeleteKnitting Bag --
ReplyDeletea) a zippered top so that the animals can't get into it (I live with a veterinarian and the accompanying menagerie)
b) a sturdy bottom that will sit flat and keep the bag upright
Beth123B on Ravelry
c) interior pockets for knitting needles, with small zippered pockets for notions and tape measure
WIP bag:
a) drawstring closure with a lock so the drawstring stays closed when the bag isn't in use.
b) sturdy bottom that sits flat and keeps the bag upright.
c) large enough to hold a large ball of yarn and a project such a shawl without crowding
DPN roll:
a) pockets big enough to hold DPN storage tubes like Nancy's Knit Knacks sells
b) at least a dozen pockets with a flap over them to keep things from slipping out
c) doesn't hold things so tightly you have to fight to get the tubes out
Sorry about that -- added my Rav ID at the last minute and didn't realize I'd stuck it in the middle of my comment!
ReplyDeleteThis is such a neat contest! The things I look for in a knitting bag are:
ReplyDelete1) It needs to be BIG! I need lots of space!
2) Good-sized straps- not too skinny, and not too long.
3) Color- it needs to come in several different varieties- I don't like carrying plain black bags
4) Inside/outside pockets- since I normally carry my knitting bag as a purse as well, I need pockets for my cell phone, chapstick, etc.
Something else I think would be neat (and I know is already out there- they just don't come together normally) would be WIP bags that match the knitting bag. It sounds like that's what you're already planning- and I think that's great. I love matching things!
1) pockets, usually knitting bags just have one large open space and don't have many pockets at all. I need pockets.
ReplyDelete2) Big enough for 14in straights to fit in (for the bigger bag). I like knitting with straights but most bags can't hold them.
3) Thick sides, possibly quilted, so that small dpns can't poke holes in the fabric.
WIP bag:
ReplyDelete- a large pocket in one side (short side, not long side) with snaps, large enough so that I can fit a ball of yarn in there and feed the pull out between the snaps.
- a sectioned off, fold over flap pocket to keep a few needles in with a side space for my tapestry needle.
- a small fully velcro'd pocket for my stitch markers.
Full size bag:
- a PUL lined outer pocket that can accomodate a 20oz water bottle
- a key fob because really, I'd rather carry my knitting bag than my purse. ;)
- a snap out needle roll. So I can have all my needles with me but it's not rolling around being a PITA
1. Contrasting lighter color inside of bag so it's not a black hole inside of the bag.
ReplyDelete2. Lot's of pockets all different sizes both for knitting supplies and seperate ones for wallet, cell phone, keys, etc. so as to leave space in center for knitting
3. Made of ligt weight material
A sturdy fabric that can be cleaned easily
ReplyDeleteBox construction for the bottom so the bag stands
Tight closure so it can be put through an airport xray machine without the contents falling
Interior pockets of varying sized but at least one that can hold a full size pattern or pattern book
Place to put a business card in case the bag is misplaced
correction to my email mckane@msn.com
ReplyDelete1 - sturdy fabric
ReplyDelete2 - lots of pockets and dividers
3 - a large or adjustable opening to make it easy to find things
WIP - attacable to main bag to easily grab and go without repacking or having more handles to carry.
Oh wow, I'm gonna have a hard time completing, but here we go!
ReplyDeleteI'll start with my WIP bag first:
1) small enough to fit in my knitting bag, but big enough to hold my 'bigger than a pair of socks' projects
2) an inner pouch that will hold my yarn cake separate from my WIP
3) a small pouch for stitch markers, mini crochet hook, mini tape measure
4)straps that fit over my shoulder if necessary
5)drawstring or snap closure
My knitting bag
1)large enough to hold several WIPS and a bottle of water and a snack, and if it has a place to hook the bottle of water that would be awesome (I have a bag that is 'fatter' at the bottom and I love using it for knitting)
2)inner pouch with a hook for my keys and room for my cell phone
3)long enough straps to fit over my shoulder and be tucked behind my back, so I can walk down a train or bus aisle without smacking people in the head even when its full, the straps should also be well attached so if I put too much in the bag they don't fall off
4) snap or zip closure
5) space to hold the patterns of the projects I'm carrying
6) able to sit on the floor without falling over
if they came filled up with sexy yarn I wouldn't be sad
Both should be washable and sturdy but not stiff
I'm Nysssa on Rav - we met through the one skein dye it yourself swap on blankie mania!
full size:
ReplyDelete- firm bottom
- zipper pocket on the inside
- zipper to close the top
- 2 handles
- a place to store needles and notions
wip:
- atleast a drawstring
- a place to keep needles and such
- an easy way to carry it
this is going to be quite a project!!! I don't have a lot to add, but I want to be in on the drawing and to let you know that I'm behind you on this idea.
ReplyDelete1. washable
2. no velcro
3. light colored lining so can see inside easier.
Wow, what a project to tackle! Most of my ideas have been listed already, but how about making it from vintage looking oilcloth for cleanability? All knitting bags should have a wide mouth, perhaps a drawstring closure? And a cute matchy pouch for notions or secret yarn $$ for those impulse purchases. I love little matchy treasures!
ReplyDelete1) No velcro or zipper...don't want to get snagged. 2) enough little pockets on the inside to hold all the little tools. I hate when everything gets jumbled in the bottom
ReplyDelete3) folder type pocket that can hold pattern pages or a book with out getting crinkled to badly...
thanks for doing this, what a neat idea... :)
i'm on ravelry cc1271
What a great non-school challenge! I would have to say my ideal knitting bag is large enough to hold a large project and the knitting book that has the pattern. Yes, I carry the book! It has a simple closure and no more than 4 pockets. I love the idea of clear vinyl pockets, so I can see what I dropped in there. The interior is a light color making it easier to see. For me, the handles allow me to easily carry the bag on my shoulder or on my arm, i.e. if I have it on my shoulder but it does slip down then it won't hit the ground as it slides down my arm.
ReplyDeleteI hope you find some of this helpful and I will be curious to see how this process goes for you and what the final product looks like.
WIP bag:
ReplyDelete1. Some kind of yarn guide, or even a separate yarn pocket + yarn guide to keep the yarn out of the way (and to keep it from jumping out of the bag)
2. Poke-proof fabric. Or at least poke-resistent fabric. My metal dpns have poked holes in several of my bags *sigh*. I guess I should really get a dpn-protector to save my poor bags...
3. Some kind of smooth, silky fabric on the inside really helps.
I have a knitting bag that is closed with two metallic purse snaps, and my only problem with it is that a small knitting can fall out when the bag is closed.
My backpack has a neat closure, I think it's designed for keeping snow out but it should work for keeping yarn in without damaging it. It's folded twice when closed and there are something sewn into the hem of the opening to make it sturdy.
Here are pictures of a similar closure:
http://www.utsidan.se/blogs/peterute/13767.htm
THIS IS SO COOL!
ReplyDelete1. Sturdy & washable (or wipeable);
2. Pockets for non-knitting stuff stuff,ie: cell phone, water bottle, snacks;
3. Pockets for knitting stuff, ie: needles, patterns, book &/or magazine, markers, needle protectors and other little knitting notions;
4. A sturdy bottom;
5. Some kind of closure, like a flap or pull string or zipper, so stuff wont fall out;
6. Two straps;
7. It would be really cool if made with my fav color, dark purple!
WIP Bag:
1. Big enough for a couple wips;
2. Some kind of sturdy clousure.
GOOD LUCK with your bags and I want to say, they are really pretty. I love them.
My favorite bag would have be tall enough to hold knitting needles. Secondly, it would have small inside slots to hold needles, larger pockets to hold a tape measure, small scissors, etc and maybe an outside pocket to hold patterns. Finally it should have lots of room for yarn and projects.
ReplyDeleteWithout reading every one of the prior comments, here are my wishlist items:
ReplyDelete1. Machine washable fabric.
2. Flat bottom wide enough to keep the bag upright when placed on the floor.
3. Wide shoulder strap that is adjustable to carry either as a simple shoulder bag or as a messenger bag and/or over a heavy winter coat sleeve.
4. I would like to have a magnetic snap closure exterior pocket for my phone, which would need to be large enough to accomodate phones from the wee tiny flip phones to the big honkin Iphone.
5. Another exterior pocket for a water bottle, like a Sigg or bicycle bottle.
6. An interior pocket large enough to carry a flat pattern or book.
7. Zip closure so that when the bag gets dropped/knocked over, all of your stuff doesn't spill into the inevitable pile of snow slush or other unpleasantness as you juggle to get your house keys into the lock.
7. An interior pocket with a zip or mag closure for a key ring.
8. A snap loop long enough to flip to the outside where I can hang my kitchener instructions dogtag and a row counter.
9. Pockets to accomodate a wee notions bag, needles, wallet, protein bar, and GPS that will guide you to the nearest yarn shop.
10. Coordinating wee notions bag and needle cases.
11. Snap loop yarn guide. Since I'm not at all monogomous to knitting projects to completion, I need to be able to get the yarn du jour in and out of the bag/guides without breaking it.
I have more thoughts, but for now need to go catch my morning train and get my hand dyed in the mail!
- A sturdy flat bottom so it doesn't tip over.
ReplyDelete- Lots of inside pockets but at least one should have a zipper.
- A few outside pockets.
- Matching/complimentary small project bag.
- Durable but not heavy fabric and a dark color on the bottom so it won't show the dirt from sitting on the ground.
Hi!! well for me my top 3 are fairly easy
ReplyDeleteenough room for a project at least sweater bits (but not so huge to appear as a weekend bag)
inner pockets for small knit related items, or cell phone
stylish and hip so it can go with me on travel without appearing to be like a diaper bag.
i'm fairly easy to please though!
I posted earlier but I forgot to mention: I want a bag that is light weight!
ReplyDeleteI have a wonderful Tom Bihn bag (Utility Tote) that would be perfect if it weren't so "sporty" looking. I want a pretty one!
Purlescence said:
ReplyDeleteMy three suggests for a perfect knitting bag:
1) Large, messenger style bag with a sturdy magnetic snap closure (so project is secured inside with out worrying about zipping your yarn!)
2) large outer pocket on the back for slipping in a magazine or book
3) inner pockets of varying shapes and sizes for notions, cell phone, pens, wallet... including one that also closes securely for your wallet.
My three suggestion for a WIP bag:
1) Double drawstring closure with straps long enough to put over your shoulder (I've always carrying way too many things!)
2) Washable or at least easy to clean fabric
3) Slim inner pockets for crochet hooks, cable needles, chibi needles, pen, etc.
Hope these suggestions help!
ok, you've got a lot of suggestions here, so I'm sure I'm reapeating some, but here are mine:
ReplyDelete1. Multiple sections (or pockets) of various sizes, - and in my ultimate bag there would be the following:
1 'section' for the project itself,
1 'section' for the yarn you'll need or another project or Extra knitting supplies
1 'pocket' for your basic knitting supplies (with button or snap - no velcro)
1 'pocket' for your pattern(s) - perhaps with a sturdy side to it, so as not to bend
and a couple extra open pockets (inside or out)and/or a couple removable pockets - for your keys, gadgets, - personal extras
2. a Sturdy strap, wide enough so it doesn't dig into your shoulder as you carry it, and not so long that the bag is hitting you in the knees.
3. waterproof lining would be nice but not necessary, but a light-colored lining to be able to see all the things that drop to the bottom
4. No velcro, but closures, so if the bag tips over, everything doesn't fall out. A couple of snaps across the top is fine, or a flap (weighted) to pull over works too.
WIP - ideas
1. water-resistant thick fabric (that won't let needles poke through) and reversible!
2. a flat bottom so it doesn't fall over
3. drawstrings pulls
4. an extra pocket inside (and I guess outside if reversible) for your needles seperately, or for a few notions - maybe with a simple snap.
5. a small strap with lobster-claw clip to attach things you dont' want to fall to the bottom of your bag
Thanks for the fun contest - it was great 'dreaming' of the perfect bag!! Can't wait to see who wins and what their creation looks like!
An attached matching luggage tag to hold
ReplyDeletebusiness-size ID card in case bag is lost.
An attached small jewelry clip to hold row counter/ a few markers.
Fabric or elastic bands to hold dpns/tube for dpns
A clear removable vinyl envelope/pocket for pattern(recipe card size is GOOD).
The small, adjustable, plastic markers might work well as a yarn guide; which I think is a good suggestion.